You don't have to like what I'm going to say, and I am always open to healthy debate. I fact-check and will include links to the topics discussed here.
The Study
A while back, I read about a study that found breed explains only 9% of behavioral differences in dogs. This piqued my interest, especially since Dalmatians are often mislabeled with breed stereotypes. Although Dalmatians weren't part of this study, it included 18,000 dogs from several breeds. Unless Dalmatians are some magical anomaly, this may very well be relevant to them too.
Direct Quote from the Study: "For some traits, like biddability and border collie ancestry, we confirm a genetic effect of breed that aligns with survey responses. For others, like human sociability and Labrador retriever ancestry, we found no significant effect."
Common Themes in Dalmatian Communities
As heavily invested Dalmatian lovers, enthusiasts, and preservation breeders, we are part of several Dalmatian communities, groups, and social circles. Some common themes we see are:
Rehoming: Dalmatians being rehomed for many reasons, often due to behavioral issues.
Behavioral Issues: Owners asking how to fix poor behavior in their Dalmatians.
Stereotypes: Dalmatians being labeled as aggressive, aloof, and not good around children or in social settings.
Destructive Behavior: Owners sharing stories of their Dalmatians chewing up furniture and finding it amusing.
Blaming Breeders: The belief that poor behavior is due to bad breeding practices.
My Thoughts
This study had me thinking: What if it's NOT the breed, but the owner? What if the lack of accountability in ownership is a huge chunk of that remaining 92% in blame for behavioral issues? What if genetics play a small, more insignificant role compared to how the dog is raised, trained, and treated?
Unfortunately for many dogs, it's their people. It's the lack of training, socialization, attention, and accountability, in combination with genetics!
Supporting Information
Owner Behavior and Dog Communication: A study from the Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History found that dogs adapt their communicative strategies based on their environment and that owner behavior significantly influences the effort and accuracy of dogs' communication.
Pre-Purchase Behaviors and Dog Welfare: Research published in MDPI highlights that owners who conduct more research before getting a dog tend to have better knowledge and understanding of dog welfare needs. This pre-purchase behavior is linked to improved ownership practices and better overall dog welfare. (source)
Impact of Owner's Mental Health: A study published in BMC Psychiatry found that dog owners' mental health, including stress and anxiety levels, can directly affect their dogs' behavior. Dogs of owners with higher stress levels exhibited more behavioral problems. (source)
Legal Responsibilities of Dog Ownership: Understanding the legal duties that come with dog ownership is crucial. A comprehensive guide from Dog Carely emphasizes that responsible ownership, including proper training and socialization, is key to ensuring the well-being of pets and adhering to societal norms and regulations.
Expectations Versus Reality in Dog Ownership: A large cross-sectional study in Australia showed that experienced dog owners had a more realistic understanding of the challenges and responsibilities of dog ownership compared to first-time owners. This realistic expectation is associated with better management of dog behavior. (source)
Additional Points
Owner's Stress and Anxiety: Did you know that your level of stress and anxiety can directly contribute to your dog's behavior?
C-BARQ Behavioral Testing: Based on C-BARQ testing, Dalmatians rank low in terms of aggressiveness. "The Dalmatian ranks number 40 out of 124 dog breeds for aggression towards strangers," with #1 being the best and #124 being the worst. (source)
This is a loaded topic, and I urge you to steer clear of the know-it-all keyboard warriors and do some research of your own!
Comments